Dofus 1.29:Community Portal/Sets

From Dofus 1.29
Jump to: navigation, search

Discussion[edit]

Since we're making pages for all items, I suggest we reduce redundant info on the set pages. We should definitely have item info so people don't have to check a new page for every item in the set, but the info should be a template. That way it'll have more consistent presentation, be easier to update, and help make sure the relevant info is included (and the non-relevant isn't). - Dashiva 16:29, 6 Dec 2005 (UTC)

Another idea popped up. Should we put all set items on the page of the set, and make the individual item pages redirect to the set page? This would prevent redundancy completely, but would require some fixing on the set structure to avoid it becoming overwhelming. - Dashiva 22:17, 22 January 2006 (UTC)
I like the latter proposal, especially because it emphasizes the importance of set membership. It seems like pages are already moving in that direction. See Country Set as an example of a set page that's missing some item pages and redirects. Has this issue been decided but only partially implemented? - TaviRider 20:03, 15 Feb 2006 (UTC)
No, those pages are a result of people adding info for the set, without actually making the item pages. Laziness is a great factor than intent. It's also doubtful that this will become policy, see Talk:Treechnid Set for an alternative proposal. - Dashiva 22:44, 15 February 2006 (UTC)
The treechnid proposal does look good, but since treechnid is dropped, it has no crafting info, so its easy to keep it clean, but for other sets that do have crafting info, I think that should still be displayed on the set page. --DameDatte 09:09, 13 June 2006 (UTC)


Wich to choose[edit]

In the past days I have been Standarizing the way the Sets pages look, giving an order to the Equipment, and part of the Effects, also have been improving part of the info, but I stumble upon the Talk:Treechnid_Set page and notice the proyect working there, I like the alternative one, because the effects are not in just a line (horizonal) with maybe other info like craft or in case of weapons the characteristics of the Weapon. So at the end... im wondering if I should redo all the other sets and use the alternative one? thought the coment about the crafting its very true will make less clean. And also the characterist on the Weapon should be add to the final total bonus? (ej 1-2 steal HP (air) Weapon damage, or -1 AP lost to target) --Cizagna 21:12, 13 July 2006 (UTC)

For crafting, you could add another column called (e.g.) obtaining, and put 'monster drop', 'subscriber gift', the craft recipe, or whatever is the case. I personally feel that item images do not belong on set pages, so I would fully support the treechnid alternative structure. - Dashiva (talk | mod) 19:55, 14 July 2006 (UTC)